The Disturbing Truth About St. Patrick’s Day and Its Brutal History
- Cyborg Studios
- Mar 17
- 5 min read
Another look into the holidays we celebrate: St. Patrick’s Day
March 17th. A day when the streets run green, bars overflow with Guinness, and the air fills with slurred renditions of "Danny Boy." For many, St. Patrick’s Day is little more than an excuse to drink excessively while donning cheap leprechaun hats. But behind the parade floats and shamrock-shaped sunglasses lies a disturbing history of cultural suppression, religious persecution, and the commodification of an entire nation's identity.
For those of us in the BDSM and kink community—where power dynamics, consent, and authenticity are core values—perhaps it's time we take a harder look at the origins of this holiday and how it became a garish spectacle that does little to honor Ireland's rich and complex past.
The Dark Origins: St. Patrick and the Eradication of Pagan Ireland
Many people assume St. Patrick’s Day is simply a celebration of Irish culture, but in truth, it honors the man credited with converting Ireland to Christianity. And that conversion? It was far from peaceful.
The most famous legend associated with St. Patrick is that he "drove the snakes out of Ireland." But here’s the twist: Ireland never had snakes. Instead, historians widely agree that this story is a metaphor for his efforts to drive out the "pagans"—the native Irish who followed their own spiritual traditions long before Christianity arrived.
According to historian Mary Condren, PhD, from Trinity College Dublin:"The story of the snake is nothing but Christian propaganda. The reality is that St. Patrick and his followers worked to dismantle Ireland’s ancient religious traditions, replacing them with Christian doctrine. The 'snakes' were the Druids, and they were driven out, not through persuasion, but through destruction."
Under Patrick’s mission, sacred sites were seized or repurposed, pagan symbols were demonized, and those who refused to convert faced punishment, exile, or even execution. The traditional Celtic belief system, which centered around nature worship, polytheism, and oral storytelling, was systematically suppressed.
One of the most glaring examples of this erasure is the shamrock, now one of the most recognizable symbols of St. Patrick’s Day. While today it's associated with Irish pride, it was originally a sacred plant used in Druidic rituals. Patrick allegedly co-opted the shamrock to explain the Christian concept of the Holy Trinity—Father, Son, and Holy Spirit—replacing its original spiritual significance.
Cultural Genocide and Forced Conversion
St. Patrick’s efforts were not an isolated event. They were part of a much larger campaign by the Catholic Church to spread Christianity across Europe, often by violence and coercion. The Vatican saw the indigenous spiritual traditions of Ireland as a threat to its power, and Patrick was one of many missionaries sent to "civilize" the so-called heathens.
Much like the forced Christianization of other regions—such as the destruction of Norse mythology in Scandinavia or the erasure of indigenous beliefs in the Americas—this campaign resulted in the loss of a rich and complex cultural identity.
As scholar Peter Berresford Ellis explains in his book The Druids:"What we call ‘Christianization’ of Ireland was, in reality, a forced restructuring of an entire society. The old gods were turned into demons, their followers turned into heretics, and their stories either erased or twisted beyond recognition."
To put it bluntly: St. Patrick’s "miracle" was nothing short of religious imperialism.
The Irish in America: From Oppression to Stereotypes
Centuries later, Ireland would face another devastating blow—the Great Famine (1845-1852), a tragedy that led to the deaths of over a million people and forced millions more to flee to America. But rather than finding refuge, Irish immigrants were met with hostility, bigotry, and brutal working conditions.
They were mocked as lazy, untrustworthy, and—most enduringly—drunken fools. Early St. Patrick’s Day celebrations in America were not about pride but about survival. They were ways for the Irish to assert their presence in a country that saw them as second-class citizens.
The infamous "No Irish Need Apply" signs were a stark reminder of how unwelcome they were. But over time, as the Irish gained political power, St. Patrick’s Day was repackaged into a celebration of "Irish pride"—one that America could commodify and sell.
Today, that legacy continues, but in a different form. The holiday has devolved into a crude spectacle where people with no real connection to Irish culture get wasted on green beer and stagger through the streets yelling, "Kiss me, I’m Irish!"
As Irish comedian Ed Byrne once put it:"St. Patrick’s Day has become the one day a year when people feel entitled to be as obnoxiously drunk as possible and call it ‘Irish culture.’"
Perpetuating Harmful Stereotypes
The modern version of St. Patrick’s Day does little to honor Ireland’s history. Instead, it reinforces harmful stereotypes that have plagued the Irish for centuries.
Consider how Hollywood and pop culture depict the Irish. Drunkenness. Fisticuffs. Leprechauns. Loud, bumbling men and feisty redheaded women. That’s what gets celebrated on March 17th—not the actual struggles and achievements of the Irish people.
And then there’s the "Plastic Paddy" phenomenon—a term used to describe people who claim Irish heritage but know nothing about the country beyond beer and shamrocks. These are the same people who wear shirts that say "Irish Today, Hungover Tomorrow" and think that ordering a Guinness makes them an honorary Dubliner.
Author Tom Hayden, in his book Irish on the Inside, puts it bluntly: "The worst insult to Irish history is not forgetting it—it’s reducing it to a drinking contest."
Should We Still Celebrate St. Patrick’s Day?
At this point, you might be wondering: Should we just cancel St. Patrick’s Day altogether?
Not necessarily. But we should rethink how we celebrate it.
Instead of treating it as an excuse for drunken debauchery, why not use the day to actually honor real Irish culture? Learn about Irish history. Read the poetry of W.B. Yeats. Listen to traditional Irish music. Support Irish businesses. Try understanding the actual struggles of the Irish, both past and present.
Most importantly, let’s stop perpetuating the outdated, offensive stereotypes that have long defined this holiday.
And if you still feel the need to party? Fine. Just don’t pretend that chugging cheap whiskey while wearing a leprechaun hat makes you "honorary Irish."
Final Thoughts
St. Patrick’s Day has been stripped of its meaning, transformed from a solemn commemoration into a corporate-fueled joke. It’s a day that mocks the very people it claims to celebrate.
If you truly care about Ireland and its history, do better.
Because let’s be honest—if someone threw a party celebrating your ancestors by turning them into drunk, bumbling cartoons, you’d be pissed too.
Comments